Hey darlin' how're you doing. I can tell you exactly what we did, Hubby had an HP finance agreement with Mazda Finance which was on their PCP scheme (balloon payment or hand keys back at the end of Yr 3). Because we were unsure whether we would get the finance next year we spoke to our IP and she kindly allowed us to part-ex a year early on the same type of scheme. We have been over to Mazda today, and Hubby has had to fill in a new credit agreement, but with the part-ex, our payments have gone down by £10 per month. We have also gone for a smaller engine, 1.6 instead of 2ltr so as you say, the insurance group and RFL will be a lot cheaper (4 insurance groups down!!!). Our new car has been ordered today, which we are really pleased about. As Melanie has said, it ensures stability over the next three years for our IVA and she was fine about approving it for us, so I hope your IP will be too. It is certainly worth an ask, as I was sure that it wouldn't be allowed, so I was pleasantly surprised. I really hope you get it sorted hun, let us know how you get on. Take Care Kazzy x